Two editorials in the July issue of the Communications of the Association for Computing Machinery ask about the decay and future of the organization itself.
Jim Larus, editor-in-chief of the CACM, writes Wither ACM? Publish and Perish?
ACM no longer has broad appeal as a professional organization, does not advance many members’ careers, and may not be a valuable affiliation in a more diverse technical world...It is time to recognize that ACM has shifted from functioning as a professional society for the academic computing community to a professional publisher....It is time for ACM members to debate what kind of organization ACM should be and how to remake it into the society they want to belong to!
Vardi writes Whither Computing? starting with the concerns of PhD students whether they made the right choice by going into computer science and ending with a call for ACM to lead the conversation.
A new team will assume the leadership of ACM on July 1, 2026, following the current general election and search for a new chief executive officer. I believe this team will have to grapple with existential questions about the future of computing as a science and a profession...If ACM is about “advancing computing as a science and profession,” then we need to engage in a deep conversation about what this phrase means today for education, research, the profession, and ACM, and about how to truly advance computing as a science and profession.
ACM hasn't served as a true professional society for a long time. Unlike in other fields, ACM doesn't hold annual meetings for the whole community, and shares the spotlight with IEEE-CS, USENIX, AAAI, CRA and others. CRA takes the lead in research and organizes the CS department chairs meetings. ACM has focused on journals, conferences through its SIGS and awards.
This worked well while computing went through tremendous growth from after the financial crisis until a couple of years ago. But now artificial intelligence is making us rethink how we do research, publish and educate. What does it even mean to be a computer scientist in the AI era?
So good luck to incoming president Elisa Bertino and her team. Computing is changing. How will ACM change with it?
No comments:
Post a Comment