Let us call a nondeterministic Turing machine M balanced if for
every input x, all of its computational paths have the same length,
i.e., the number of nondeterministic bits depends only on x and not on
previous guesses. We can define the characterize class BPP as follows:
L is in BPP if there is a balanced nondeterministic polynomial-time M such that
If x is in L then there are at least twice as many accepting as
rejecting paths of M(x).
If x is not in L then there are at least twice as many rejecting
as accepting paths of M(x).
Suppose we use the same definition without the "balanced"
requirement. This gives us the class BPPpath studied mostly
in a 1997
paper of Han, Hemaspaandra and Thierauf.
BPPpath contains BPP by definition but it contains much
more. Let us show that SAT is contained in BPPpath.
Let φ be a formula with n variables. Consider the following
machine M(φ): Guess an assignment a for φ. If a is rejecting
then reject. If a is accepting then guess n+1 bits, ignore them and
accept.
If φ is not satisfiable then M(φ) will only have rejecting
paths. If φ is satisfiable then it will have at least
2n+1 accepting paths and at most 2n-1 rejecting
paths fulfilling the requirements of the definition of
BPPpath.
Han, Hemaspaandra and Thierauf prove many other results about
BPPpath. The class contains MA and
PNP[log] (P with O(log n) queries to an NP language like
SAT). BPPpath is contained in
PΣ2[log], BPPNP and
PP.
Whether BPPpath is contained in ZPPNP or Σ2 remain
the most interesting open questions about this class.